Faithful Conversations #118

Introduction to Readers

“People who’ve had any genuine spiritual experience always know that they don’t know. They are utterly humbled before mystery. They are in awe before the abyss of it all, in wonder at eternity and depth, and a Love, which is incomprehensible to the mind.”
~ Richard Rohr (Franciscan Priest)

Monday marks the 36th day of Eastertide, the sacred 50-day journey from Easter Sunday to Pentecost on June 8. Throughout these seven weeks, the Lectionary readings highlight resurrection, renewal, and the Church’s early expansion. This week, the opening quote from Christian mystic Richard Rohr resonated deeply with me, especially as Thursday approaches—the day that commemorates the Ascension of our Lord. After His Resurrection, Jesus walked the earth for 40 days before ascending into heaven, a moment of profound mystery (Acts 1: 1-11 and Luke 24: 44-53). The Ascension serves as a bridge between heaven and earth, mortality and eternity. Across Christian traditions, it remains a cornerstone of faith and worship, intricately tied to eschatology—the belief in Christ’s second coming — a connection we have with Christians across time since that incredible moment.

Some quick background. Since the earliest days of Christianity, believers have celebrated the Feast of the Ascension—also known as Ascension Day or Holy Thursday—to honor Jesus’ bodily ascent into heaven, as recorded in Luke’s Gospel. By the 4th century, Christians, particularly in the Eastern Church, widely observed the feast, and by the 6th century, the Western Church formally established it. Traditionally held forty days after Easter, Ascension Day falls on a Thursday, though some denominations move it to Sunday to allow more worshippers to take part. Over time, churches have deepened the celebration with processions, prayers, and solemn services. More than a historical event, Ascension Day proclaims Christ’s heavenly reign and his promise to return in glory, filling believers with hope and anticipation.

This day is highlighted in the Lectionary (one of several beyond Sundays), but my sense is that it goes by without much notice. In our various books of worship prior to the 1978 green hymnal, the calendar of the church year received more emphasis than in our new versions. If you are 65 or older, for example, the 1958 red hymnal would be familiar to you. Note the Introit and Collect for Ascension Day (below), utilized at the beginning of the worship service, words you may have heard growing up. Keep them in mind as you navigate the readings for both Ascension Day and the Seventh Sunday of Easter.

Thanks for visiting this space again and for your continued interest in exploring the Lectionary! We have two notable commemorations this week: John Calvin, Renewer of the Church, died on 27 May in 1564. And the visit of Mary to Elizabeth is marked on Saturday, 31 May (The image on the left, The Embrace of Elizabeth and the Virgin Mary (c. 1191), is from a church in Macedonia). This week, my reflections center on a significant historical milestone—the 1700th anniversary of the Council of Nicaea (May–August, 325 CE), a pivotal moment in Christian history. I invite you to explore how this event connects with the readings assigned for both Thursday and Sunday. And one note: I include links out for further information and they are in bold print and italicized.

Common Themes Among the Readings

Reflection: “being of one substance”

Christian denominations like the ELCA actively shape their core beliefs and cultivate theological unity. They immerse believers in the Church’s rich historical traditions, preserving and passing down the faith that has endured since early Christianity. Creeds enunciate complex doctrines, transforming them into accessible teachings that strengthen spiritual formation through worship and instruction. As catalysts for ecumenical dialogue, creeds foster unity among diverse Christian traditions, building connections despite theological differences. Ultimately, they anchor churches in shared doctrine while forging lasting bridges across generations and denominations. The three great ecumenical statements of faith within Christendom are the Apostles’, Nicene, and Athanasian Creeds. The ELCA affirms all three as foundational expressions of our faith, and all are recognized in the ELCA’s governing documents and Lutheran confessional writings compiled in the Book of Concord. We recite the Apostles’ Creed every Sunday and the Nicene Creed occasionally. (Sidebar: I do not recall ever having used the Athanasian Creed. In fact, you will not find it in the ELW, our current hymnal, which seems surprising — a story for another day!).

Let’s do a bit of time-tripping regarding the second of those belief statements, the Nicene Creed. As mentioned in my introduction, the summer of 2025 marks the 1700th anniversary of the famous meeting that produced this creed, the Council of Nicaea. From May through August of 325 CE, bishops from across the Roman Empire gathered in Nicaea, near Lake Ascanius in modern-day Turkey, to settle a major dispute about Christ’s nature. Arius, a priest from Alexandria, argued that Jesus was created and not fully divine, while others, like Athanasius (think Athanasian Creed), insisted he was equal to the Father. As the debates intensified, tensions ran high, and according to legend, St. Nicholas of Myra (yes, THAT St. Nicholas!) became so enraged by Arius’ arguments that he slapped or punched him in the heat of the discussion, a moment that I must admit, made me laugh when I heard of it! (This dramatic act, by the way, led to Nicholas being temporarily removed from the council until Emperor Constantine reinstated him). Ultimately, the council rejected Arianism, declaring Jesus homoousios—of the same essence as God—and formalized this belief in the Nicene Creed. Constantine supported the decision and ordered Arius to be exiled, banning his writings and declaring him a heretic. Meanwhile, the Nicene Creed became the foundation of Christian doctrine, shaping the Church for centuries.

My account here is a shorthand version of a complicated debate that went on far beyond 325! (Sidebar: Professor Philip Jenkins of Baylor University has written an excellent article in the May issue of The Christian Century that you may want to explore). Suffice to say, however, the Council of Nicaea proved to be a major turning point in Christian history. The council rejected Arianism and affirmed that Jesus is fully God, just like the Father. And further, this council led to the creation of the Nicene Creed, a statement of faith that Christians still use today. The Roman Emperor Constantine wanted a stronger, united Church to help stabilize his rule (we could have a lengthy discussion if this embrace of Christianity by the state was a good thing or not, but I digress!). The council’s decisions shaped Christianity for centuries, influencing future church gatherings and theological teachings.

As you read the words of the creed below, notice the careful use of language regarding that debate about Christ’s divinity (I encourage you to read it several times this week!). The Arian controversy is like a storm that shaped Christianity forever and offers a good reminder of how history shapes our present experience. In 325 AD, church leaders gathered at the Council of Nicaea to settle a fiery debate: Was Jesus fully God, or just created by Him? They stood their ground, declaring Christ eternal and equal to the Father (“being of one substance”), a belief now woven into the fabric of Christian worship through the Nicene Creed. Even today, some groups challenge this teaching, keeping the conversation alive in theology and interfaith dialogue. The echoes of that ancient dispute still ring through churches, shaping faith, unity, and how Christians see the heart of their belief—Jesus Himself. We live within an unfinished dialogue. 1 Corinthians 13:12: “For now we see in a mirror dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall know fully, even as I have been fully known.”

Soli Deo Gloria!

Note: The Sixth World Conference on Faith and Order will be held at the St. Bishoy Monastery in Wadi El Natrun, near Alexandria, Egypt, from October 24-28, 2025. This event is part of the World Council of Churches’ (WCC) year-long commemoration of the 1700th anniversary of the First Council of Nicaea. The conference will bring together church leaders, theologians, and ecumenists from various traditions to explore the theme “Where now for visible unity?”. Discussions will focus on the interconnected aspects of faith, mission, and unity, reflecting on how the Nicene Creed continues to shape Christian identity and cooperation today.

Prayer Reflection: “Refreshing our Memory” (Henri Nouwen)

“I am struck by the fact that the prophets speaking about the future of Israel always kept reminding their people of God’s great works in the past. They could look forward with confidence because they could look backward with awe to Yahweh’s great deeds. All this seems extremely important in a time in which our sense of history is so weak…. Without anchors in its early promises and aspirations, a nation is in danger of drifting and losing direction. And not only a nation but the Church as well. It seems that progress is always connected with a refreshing of our collective memory.“

My prayer for us, prompted by Nouwen’s reflection:

God of our history and hope, You have led us through trials and triumphs, teaching us wisdom from the footsteps of those before us. Guide our hearts to honor the past, and give us courage to walk boldly into the future, trusting always in Your unfailing love. Amen.

A Musical Offering:
“Sure On This Shining Night“

When I first heard Lauridsen’s musical interpretation of James Agee’s poem, I felt God’s presence — I don’t know if that’s what the poet or Lauridsen intended, but the music and words prompted that. The imagery of kindness watching over him suggests divine care, while the line “all is healed, all is health” echoes themes of restoration and peace. His weeping for wonder mirrors the human soul’s longing for God, much like the psalmist’s awe in Psalm 8. Ultimately, the poem captures the feeling of being alone yet surrounded by the sacred, drawing the reader into a sense of divine mystery and grace. It also fits well with the quote I cited in the introduction by Richard Rohr. Enjoy!

Update on “Faithful Conversations”

Our regular gatherings for discussing the weekly lectionary are on a pause. Summer worship at ELC is at 8:30 in town and 10:15 at Hatfield by the lake. The 8:30 service will be streamed. Please stay in touch!

Introduction to Bible Study

A few weeks back, I shared this link to the on-line class I put together and am reposting now as we get into the summer phase of the Lectionary. If you’re looking for a “reboot” on how to approach Bible study, take a look! Click on the photo for access!